Is Your Dog Scared of Strangers? Try These 15 Expert Tips
Does your dog get anxious around new people?
You’re definitely not alone.
Many dogs feel uneasy or stressed when meeting strangers, often due to lack of socialization, past trauma, or it’s just their personality.
The good news is, you can help.
By recognizing your dog’s signs of fear and understanding her triggers, you can make a world of difference in helping her feel more comfortable around new people.
But there’s a caveat.
I’ve shared my life with enough rescue dogs to know that some dogs will always be wary of strangers (or most of them, at least) and prefer to keep their distance.
So if your dog doesn’t want to meet new people, there’s no need to force her into uncomfortable situations or try to change her nature.
Not everyone is a social butterfly, so my advice is to embrace your dog’s unique personality and respect her boundaries.
It’ll be less pressure for you too!
Having said that, there are several things you can do to make your dog more comfortable around people she doesn’t know, so here are my 12 tips:
New E-Book
👉 My new E-book, The Fearless Fido Formula: 15 Mistakes Smart Dog Parents Never Make Again is officially live!
👉 If you’re a dog parent, especially of a fearful pup, this is for YOU!
👉 AND…you’ll get 4 amazing bonuses for FREE!
#1. Manage the Environment
Understanding when your dog is calm and relaxed versus when she’s stressed is key to helping her overcome her fear of strangers.
Pay attention to her signals so you can adjust your approach to meet her needs.
If that means changing direction or using a parked car or a tree as a barrier until the person has walked past, then that’s fine.
If it means placing her in a separate room with a stuffed KONG toy to keep her busy when you have visitors, that’s fine too.
If you manage situations carefully like this, it will help your dog feel safe.
Because she knows you’ll never force her into situations that make her uncomfortable.
It’s also a great way to build her confidence and trust.
When dogs feel safe, they can think clearly and make good decisions, meaning they are in the right frame of mind to learn new behaviors.
It is much harder – if not impossible – to respond to training if they are already “over threshold,” growling and barking at an unfamiliar person.
#2. Recognize Signs of Fear
The signs of fear in dogs can vary – from subtle body language to more obvious reactions.
Subtle signs might include:
- Avoiding eye contact
- Tucking the tail
- Flattening the ears
- Turning away
- Rigid posture
- Raised hackles
Overt reactions may include:
#3. Keep Your Dog Under Threshold
When helping dogs deal with any type of fear or phobia, it’s important to keep them “under threshold.”
This means making sure they don’t get so scared that they lose control.
Imagine a person losing their temper—they can’t think straight or control what they say and do.
The same thing happens with dogs.
If a dog goes over threshold, she becomes reactive and can’t think clearly or follow any training cues.
So, it’s all about managing her environment to keep her feeling safe and avoiding overwhelm, while gradually desensitizing her to triggers (in this case, people she doesn’t know) at a pace she can handle.
If we are successful, then this allows her to stay under threshold and learn more adaptive behaviors.
Some key points to note about working under threshold:
- A dog’s threshold can be crossed by excitement, fear, or other intense emotions. Signs a dog is nearing threshold include loss of interest in treats, fixation on a trigger, ignoring cues from their owner, stiffening posture, and growling.
- Over-threshold behaviors include barking, lunging, jumping, freezing, and zoomies. The dog is reacting rather than thinking and cannot learn in this state.
- Working a dog over threshold is counterproductive and will not lead to learning or behavior change. Training should only be attempted when your dog is under threshold and able to focus on you.
#4. Practical Training Techniques
Let’s look at how this would work in practice.
Start by rewarding your dog for staying calm around people she doesn’t know.
Begin at a distance where she feels comfortable, watching her body language.
You will also need to control the amount of time your dog spends around unfamiliar people (i.e. duration) and how close or overwhelming those encounters are (i.e. intensity).
Gradually decrease the distance, increase the duration, and adjust the intensity, but not all at the same time.
This process should be at your dog’s pace and never rushed.
Always monitor for signs of anxiety and end the exposure before she becomes stressed.
The goal is to keep your pup calm and responsive, allowing her to interact without feeling overwhelmed.
Gradually increasing exposure in this controlled way helps build confidence and positive associations with meeting new people.
- Rewards: Offering treats, play, or praise when your dog remains calm around strangers serves as positive reinforcement, which means the behavior will be strengthened and more likely to repeat itself.
- Consistency: Regular practice maintains these positive behaviors.
#5. Preparing for Visitors
Visitors to your home should not initially attempt to pet or make eye contact with your dog.
Instead, have them gently toss treats on the floor near your dog.
This helps your dog associate strangers with rewards at a distance she feels comfortable with.
Allow her to retreat if she wants, and if she decides to engage, don’t make a big deal of it.
Just have the visitor continue gently tossing treats away from themselves while avoiding direct eye contact or talking to the dog.
The goal is to make the initial meeting with a new person a non-threatening experience for your dog.
By asking your visitor to remain somewhat indifferent to your dog and avoiding direct eye contact and excessive attention, which can be intimidating, you create a more comfortable environment.
Calmly tossing a few treats in your dog’s direction can help forge a positive association, subtly signaling that new faces bring good things.
#6. Create a Safe Space
A sense of security is crucial for your dog’s comfort.
To this end, ensure she has a designated safe space in your home, like a quiet room or area, that she can retreat to whenever she wants to.
This can help alleviate feelings of stress.
For added comfort during high-stress moments, consider tools such as a Thundershirt or soothing pheromone sprays, which can further promote feelings of safety.
- Safe Haven: A designated quiet area where your dog can escape from overwhelming situations.
- Accessibility: This area should always be available to your dog when you have visitors, house guests, or visiting tradespersons.
#7. Real-World Training
When you’re outside your home, you can begin your training in a low-stress environment such as a park where there is sufficient space to control the distance between your dog and strangers.
Always keep your dog on a leash for safety and reassurance.
This way, you can control the situation and let her move away if she starts to get scared.
Watch for signs that she’s uncomfortable and give her the space to retreat if she wants to.
This helps prevent any bad experiences that could make her fear worse.
Keep your training sessions positive with treats and praise to reward calm behavior.
As your dog’s comfort levels increase, you can gradually reduce the distance to strangers, always respecting your dog’s threshold.
- Initial Step: Start with ample distance in a park.
- Progression: Slowly decrease the space between your dog and the people.
- Positive Reinforcement: Use treats and verbal praises when your dog remains calm and non-reactive.
#8. Desensitization and Counterconditioning
Officially, this process is known as desensitization and counterconditioning.
- Desensitization: Increase your dog’s exposure to strangers gradually at a distance he can handle.
- Counterconditioning: Pair the presence of strangers with something your dog loves, like a fun game or a jackpot of high value treats that he doesn’t have access to any other time (think chunks of cheese, hotdog, chicken…).
Desensitization and counterconditioning should always work to the dog’s timeline.
In other words, work with where your dog is at, rather than where you want her to be or think she should be.
Usually, desensitization and counterconditioning training programs are best implemented under the guidance of a professional.
#9. Avoid Forcing Interactions
When it comes to socializing your dog, it’s crucial to avoid forcing interactions.
Forcing your dog to meet people can lead to fear biting, as she may feel threatened or cornered.
Instead, let your dog approach strangers on her own terms.
Allow your dog to take the lead, deciding when and how to engage with new people.
This approach helps build trust and confidence, as your dog learns that she can explore social situations at a pace that feels safe and comfortable.
By respecting your dog’s boundaries and giving her the freedom to choose her interactions, you can prevent negative experiences and foster a more positive, relaxed attitude towards meeting new people.
#10. Establish Consistent Training Routines
Teach your dog essential life skills like ‘sit,’ ‘wait,’ come,’ leave it,’ and so on, which will give her confidence and give you a better sense of control around strangers.
- Training Routines: Stick to regular, short, positive reinforcement-based training sessions. A few short minutes is far more effective than a long hour when everyone is getting tired, bored, and frustrated.
- Life Skills and Manners: Teach your dog essential skills to provide mental engagement and promote good behavior you can use as a back-up in tricky situations.
#11. Provide Regular Physical and Mental Exercise
Regular activity helps manage your dog’s energy levels and keep his mind engaged, which can help promote an overall calmer state of mind, thereby reducing fear-driven behaviors.
- Physical Exercise: Daily walks or play sessions to expel energy and promote a positive mood state.
- Mental Stimulation: Interactive toys and problem-solving activities like sniffing games provide a mental challenge and keep your dog’s mind sharp. I throw down a handful of treats for our rescue dogs Lennox and Esme to sniff out any time a stranger comes too close when we are out on our walks. This means they’ll be focused on the game rather than worrying about the presence of someone they don’t know. Plus, sniffing lowers a dog’s blood pressure and heart rate, meaning they’ll be more relaxed.
#12. Avoid Punishment
Punishing your dog for fear-driven reactions such as barking or growling does not address her underlying fear.
Not only that, but it risks exacerbating aggressive behavior and creating a negative association with the presence of unfamiliar people.
Instead of using force, emphasize positive training techniques that reinforce desired behaviors without instilling additional anxiety.
- Focus: Reinforce what you want (calmness) rather than punishing undesirable reactions.
- Outcomes: Punishment may heighten reactive responses and damage trust, so focus on building a relationship where your dog feels safe and confident.
#13. Ensure Proper Socialization from a Young Age
If you have the option, start socialization early to help your dog become more comfortable around a variety of people and environments.
Dogs that meet a variety of people and have positive interactions with them during the sensitive period of development (3-14weeks of age), tend to grow up
Dogs that meet a variety of people and have positive interactions during the sensitive developmental period (3-14 weeks of age) are more likely to grow up more confident around unfamiliar people and environments.
- Diverse Experiences: Introducing your dog to different people and settings early on builds confidence.
- Positive Experiences: Ensuring each interaction is pleasant for your dog encourages calm and friendly behavior.
You can do this with older dogs too, but it may take longer.
#14. Patience and Consistency
The journey to overcoming fear is not a sprint—it’s a marathon.
Training to build confidence is most effective when it is applied gradually and without pressure.
Consistent, gentle encouragement can lead to lasting trust, rather than attempting to speed up the process, which might intensify your dog’s fears instead.
#15. Professional Behavior Modification
In cases of extreme fear, it’s worth drawing on the expertise of a certified professional.
Look for trainers who specialize in positive reinforcement techniques, and consider professionals with credentials such as Canine Good Citizen certification, which can indicate a high level of training expertise.
Here’s a brief guide on what to expect from a training and behavior professional:
- Assessment: An evaluation of your dog’s specific fears, triggers, and behaviors.
- Customized Plan: A training regimen tailored to your dog’s unique needs.
- Tools: Guidance on using tools such as a basket muzzle for safety if needed.
- Support: Regular sessions and support, ensuring you’re not alone in this journey.
A veterinarian can also be an integral part of the support system, especially if your dog’s fear is rooted in past abuse, trauma, or health-related issues.
Your vet can discern if medical intervention will complement behavioral training.
READ NEXT
NEED A DOG TRAINER OR BEHAVIOR EXPERT? If you need more help dealing with a training or behavior issue, please find professional help from a force-free dog trainer who can consult with you either in person or remotely. GOOD PLACES TO START ARE: - COAPE Association of Pet Behaviourists and Trainers - Pet Dog Trainers of Europe - International Companion Animal Network - Institute of Modern Dog Trainers - Pet Professional Guild All dog owners deserve to have successful relationships with their canine companions!
